jueves, 15 de noviembre de 2012

One More Foul. Pardon me: One more FALLACY



As I started reading Gandhi’s famous speech at Kingsley Hall, I was not able to spot the fallacies as quickly as I thought I would. Nevertheless as I read it several times, I found what I believe could be examples of fallacies. Gandhi was able to use fallacies hidden within his other use of rhetoric.  When in his speech he says, “It is not a blind law, for no blind law can govern the conduct of living being….” Other than using the fallacy of antecedent, as Daniel Solano said in his blogs, he could also be using the fallacy of many questions. When Gandhi says that there is a law, but not a “blind law”, he is already stating that there is something “governing everything”. Then he says that “no blind law can govern the conduct of living being”, here as Daniel said he is using fallacy of antecedent because if Gandhi says it, he probably is talking from background knowledge and how “blind laws” haven’t work in the past. So yes, he is using fallacy of antecedent, but also the fallacy of many questions, because he squashed two issues into one, “so that a conclusion proves another conclusion” (Heinrichs, 147). Other than this he also used tautology. Congrats Gandhi, three fallacies in one, just one more so you get your fourth foul, and out (just kidding).

The use of tautology was also very constant, as he kept repeating throughout the speech the same ideas. As Heinrichs said, when using tautology “the proof and the conclusion agree perfectly… because they are the same thing” (146). An example could be when he said, “humble and mute acceptance of divine authority makes life's journey easier even as the acceptance of earthly rule makes life under it easier.” As you can see I made the word “easier” in italic, because it is one of the reasons I believe it could classify as tautology: repeating words. Other than repeating words, the two ideas expressed in this sentence ended up with same conclusion. This was not the only example of tautology Gandhi presented. As the speech kept unraveling, he repeated more than once,  “that people don’t know who rules” and in other words, “villagers…did not know who ruled.” I’m not going to keep on exposing the types of fallacies used, not because I’m fearless, but because I wasn’t able to find more.

Oh look, I myself used a fallacy: “he repeated more than once.”
Gandhi, you and I have more in common that you could ever know.



*Note after having class: not sure anymore if my first example classified as a fallacy of many questions is correct, just saying!

domingo, 11 de noviembre de 2012

Never Argue The Inarguable


After learning more about fallacies, the closer I am to understanding it's use. I've come up with a conclusion, fallacies are arguments that make absolutely no sense. Sometimes you can get away with it, but when you don't, you can look like a first grader trying to solve a square root AKA ridiculous. I make fallacies more than I would rather do, but nothing compared to the King and Queen of fallacies (my parents). If you are a “wise-ass” you won’t get trap in your parent’s favorite way of using rhetoric, but if you aren’t, well prepare for a nice-stay-at-home-type-of-childhood.


This video can be an example of a type of fallacy, the power fallacy, "the person on top wants it, so it must be good"(156). The way this is used in this commercial is because the person on top, the oven, is telling Scott what to do, therefore he does it. The oven has a power...badass oven.

Ok, moving on.

Fallacies aren’t the only always you can get a foul in the game of rhetoric. According to Heinrichs there are seven of them, these are like his “deadly sins”. So if you are going to argue do it right, if not you know what they say (I don’t know what they say but it sounded like a good way to conclude my argument) ________________.
I lost myself.
Lets get back to the seven fouls:

“Switching tenses away from the future” (170). This “sin” can be seen frequently in debates between politicians. Let’s say the first candidate of a presidential election says “He did an utter disaster of the country.” Well ok A for effort, but the argument would be much better if it was in deliberative format rather than in forensic or demonstrative. I would rather vote for someone who says, “He did an utter disaster of the country, if I get elected as president I will do [such] and [such] differently to get the country back on track.” If the first candidate does no get back to future tense, “the argument is dead on arrival” (163).

“Inflexible insistence on the rules – using the voice of God, sticking t your gums, refusing to hear the other side” (170). Yeap, what he said.

“Humiliation – an argument that sets out only to debase someone not to make a choice” (170). We all know what humiliation is.

“Innuendo” (167). Self – Explanatory… NOT. I’m not going to deny it but the first things that came to mind with this word were: a video game and a type of Chinese martial arts. But it really just is a type of humiliation

BOSS: “It’s nice to see you wear a tie” (167).
ME: “I always wear a tie” (167).

In other words… you’ve just been BURN.

“Threats” (170). We all know what threats are, at least I hope.

"Nasty language or signs" (170). Just avoid those f*&$@, S%^+=, and b@!#$, that sometimes escape us when not paying attention. If doing a video you can putt a sort of “PIIII” noise while you say those nasty words, just like they do in movies.
Oh well, just try avoiding those words.

"Utter Stupidity" (170). Pretty self – explanatory, but pretty  fun to explain as well. I have to agree with Gabriela, when she says that sometimes people whose argument’s are so ignorant that they win just because there is no way to convince them that they are wrong. Here is an example:

JOHN: The sky is red.
ME: No, it’s blue.
JOHN. Not its not, are you blind?
ME: No, are you
JOHN: Just look up, it’s red!

So, that was a really bad example. But as you can see  there get’s a point that "me" just ends up agreeing that the sky is red, because like Gabriela said, “you will eventually get bored.” One might think most people avoid this “sin,” but is more common that Spanglish at CNG (sorry I just wanted to end my blog with a metaphor).

That was the lesson for today kids!

martes, 6 de noviembre de 2012

Once Again Heinrichs Proved Me Wrong

After reading Chapter 13 of Jay Heinrichs book, Thank You For Arguing, I now have for certain that I’ve always had an erroneous idea of how “bad logic” really works. According to Heinrichs parents usually respond with bad logic such as, “If your friends told you to go jump in a lake…” To be honest, this has always worked with me, I thought to myself that this argument made all the sense in the world. Oh what a fool I used to be. I believed this was perhaps the best logic one could use in an argument, but once again this book proved me wrong.


Leaving bad logic to a side, let’s focus on how logos really are used correctly, and where it really shines. For example in defense, logos can be the easiest way to back up your argument, and just burn your opponent. After all the person you are arguing against is not going to “fact-check every argument” (122). Who knows maybe everything Mr. Tangen tells us in class is a lie, but we as student trust him enough not to go look it up in the internet and if with did not trust him we would not get the time to “fact-check” ever single thing he tells us. After all, its all a lie.
Persuasion ALERT
Hyperbole: an exaggeration. This is by far one of the types of rhetoric I use more often than I should.  Say something like, "I've been to this movies a thousand times, it's the best movie ever made." Let me tell you something I would trust the guy above a million times more than someone that has seen it a hundred times (no punintended). Hyperboles (exaggerations), are often used in commercials that are trying to sell a product. Lets take this Cover Girl commercial: other than using ethos, it is also using hyperboles. For example, when Sofia Vergara says, “one pump covers… wrinkles,” she is exaggerating. Because let’s face if you are one-hundred years old, not even god can cover does wrinkles and much less a Cover Girl product.


In this Chapter, Heinrichs introduced us to other terms such as enthymeme that I already knew...NOT. If you know what it means, congrats, if you don't, here is my home-made definition (actually the book's with a little help from his pal, Wikipedia).

Enthymeme: it is an argument  or a "logic sandwich" in which the premise is not expressed (125). "In an enthymeme, part of the argument is missing because it is assumed" (wikipedia).
"We should [choice], because [commonplace]" (133).

Almost forgot the two types of logic, but here they are: deductive and inductive logic.

Inductive Logic: give information and apply formula.

Deductive Logic: starts with a common place - and applies it to reach a conclusion.

Last but not least, what we've all been waiting for... paradigm. Paradigm is "a rule that you apply to the choice you want your audience to make" (131). Almost missed, but thanks to the side note titled Meanings I now completed the task of this blog.

I have nothing else to say, so see you next entry ;)!


jueves, 1 de noviembre de 2012

Ohh... Vocab

Have you ever wondered what vocabulary words Heinrichs introduced in Chapters 11 and 12? If you have keep on reading, if you haven't you know how to leave. In this chapters a lot of new terms were introduced which I am going to explain. 

For "cracking good clichés" we should talk about common place, which has five terms that should be defined:

The Advantageous: Persuasion that makes the audience believe your own choice to be an advantageous one. This device also deals with choices of the future.


In this video the persuaders, being the people that work at apple, talk about all the features and characteristics of the new Iphone 5. They make you believe that the right thing to do is buying the new phone they released. They explain how it is going to be beneficial for the audience to buy this phone due to all its features, therefore using "the advantageous."

The Common Place: Any cliche, belief, or value that can serve as your audience's boiled-down public opinion. This is also the starting point of an argument.



In this video, we can see Martin Luther King's famous speech I Have a Dream. This could be considered a common place, because all the ideas that he transmitted were were beliefs that the audience shared. As the book says, "common place takes advantage of the way humans process information"(101). When MLK talks, the people that are hearing his arguments can see the point of view of people with color which makes people process the information of the speech differently, therefore using common place. 

Babbling: When your audience repeats the same thing over and over, it is probably mouthing a commonplace. 
According to the definition of the book, babbling is when you "repeat the things over and over" until you reach a commonplace. In this video Stewie repeats her mom's name in a lot of different ways, until he finally get's what he values (commonplace) which was his mom's attention. This is one way in which babbling could be applied.

The Common Label: Applying a common place to an idea, a proposal, or apiece of legislation; anyone who opposes it will risk seeming like an outsider.

In this video Obama talks about his take in foreign policy, meanwhile Romney offers a different one. In the begin of the video Obama talks about what he thinks should happen, and what Romney has said in those topics in past encounters (in which he disagreed), Therefore Obama made Romney look like an outsider, and at the same time used "the common label."

The Rejection: When your audience turns you down, listen to the language and identify the common place.


As we move on to Chapter 12, we stop talking about "common place" and start talking about the "specific techniques for labeling." So here they are for your own knowledge:

Term Changing: Don't accept terms your opponent uses, instead use your own.

Redefinition: Change the connotation of your opponent's terms.

Definition Jujitsu: Use your opponent's terms to attack if they favor you.

Definition Judo: Use terms that contrast with your opponent's, making them look bad.


*The videos attached to the definitions above don't just apply to those terms, but to other aswell.

domingo, 28 de octubre de 2012

The Reappearance of the Number Three


The second major element of ethos is practical wisdom. When reading Thank Your for Arguing by Jay Heinrichs I realized how much I use this tool of rhetoric. To apply this you must know your audience so you know their problems, and what they want to hear as solutions. Also the audience has to believe that you know what is the right thing to do. Practical wisdom is not what one could call book smart, but more like life smart. I believe that usually people that use this tactic are leaders, so to all the people out there in the Leadership program go use it and win all you arguments. 



Have you ever seen Phineas and Ferb, if you have then you most know how Phineas always knows what to do. The first twenty seconds into this video, Phineas already said "I know what we are going to do today." This can be considered an example of practical wisdom. This character is someone that the audience can rely on because he is considered as "sufficiently knowledgeable to deal with the problem at hand. Ok, so let's get more into detail of what practical wisdom is all about. This element of ethos has three subcategories or tools that one can use as techniques (Oh Aristotle, once again with your number three). This tools are:
  • Show off your experience
  • Bend the rules
  • Seem to take the middle course

So showing off your experience, so similar to bragging but at the same time so different. If in an argument or a conversation one starts to talk about past experiences, your point of view sound more credible. In this tool of ethos, the deliberative and demonstrative rhetoric is in use. When you talk about past experiences (demonstrative), the audience other than believing that you're more credible, they can also believe that due to your past when a similar situation is presented in the future (deliberative) you will know the right thing to do. After, "it is fine yo brag about experiences, rather than yourself" (68). 

The we can bend the rules, this tool is pretty straight forward, "if the rules don't apply, don't apply them" (68). This can be used in all types of life situations. For example, we can analyze how school tardies can "bend the rules." If some random person got late for the third time in a row, they would probably get a detention slip, but if that person were to be injured in the leg he/she would probably not get the detention slip because the rule would be bend for the handicapped. 

Last but not least we can "seem to take the middle course" which can make the audience believe your "adversary's postion is an extreme one" (69). This can be used in arguments, and after all most people prefer to make a decision that is between extremes, not too low or too high. For those who didn't understand, here is an example:

Me: Mom I want those Gucci Shoes.
Mom: No, they are two expensive.
Dad: Buy the one's in Exito, they are really cheap.
Me: But due to the price, they are bad quality.
Me: Why don't I get the Converse, they are not that expensive and they are good quality.
Dad: Ok, let's buy those.

As you can see, in this example the person trying to convince their parents (me) went with a decision that "lies midway between extremes"(69). I didn't buy the too expensive or the too cheap, but the shoes that lied in the middle. After all I got what I really wanted, because I never really desired the Gucci ones.

Oh, the beauty of rhetoric.